Why Dissatisfied Employees Aren’t a Bad Thing

Several weeks ago I was reading through my LinkedIn updates when an article title caught my eye—Why You Need Dissatisfied Employees. “Really?” I asked myself.  Everything we hear as business owners tells us we what we need to do to keep our employees and our staff satisfied.

So, I read the article, and with my curiosity piqued, I contacted the author, Robert Sher. I learned that Robert is the founder  of CEO to CEO, a firm that improves the skills of chief executives of midmarket companies who are navigating major shifts in their business or their marketplace, the author of The Feel of the Deal: How I Built My Company Through Acquisitions and is a columnist on Forbes.com. After exchanging a few emails, I invited him to be my radio guest and share his thoughts.

A few of the interview highlights are excerpted below. For the full interview, listen to the show’s archived podcast.

Kelly: Why are dissatisfied employees critical to a high performance work environment?

Robert: When you first think about it, you ask, “How can that be? We want people to be happy and comfortable in their jobs.” But when you look at the research, what jumps out is that people who are really engaged, are engaged in accomplishing a specific goal. And at the heart of that desire to accomplish that goal is the sense of dissatisfaction. Let’s just step out of the business world just for a minute and think of an Olympic athlete who is training for the gold medal. Is that athlete satisfied? Not at all. Then from a workplace perspective, when you have a team that is comfortable in their jobs, that’s not the kind of team that’s going to drive your business to the next level. When I’ve had employees in my company who were a little dissatisfied with the results they were achieving and were trying to perform better, that’s when the organization moved forward. For example, when you have a shipping crew that gets a little upset when something comes back damaged or when there’s a ½ % error rate, that dissatisfaction is going to cause them to improve.

Kelly: Obviously, before you can have a high-performance environment, you have to be able to recognize the signs of a low-performance environment and do something about it. In your experience, what are the common causes of low performance in the workplace?

Robert: What I see with all my clients are five common causes. The first is that it is not clear what each individual and each team is supposed to do. Is the sales team supposed to just sell more at any price, or are they supposed to focus on new accounts, or grow current accounts?

The second is that the definitions of success and failure are not crystal clear. If I’m a sales person, how much must I sell? Having the definition of “success” be clear brings it to the front of employees’ minds.  They know, “If I can get to “X”, then I win.” Now making failure clear is the other side of this for productive work environments that want to take it to the next level. Essentially saying, “If you don’t at least do X, we’ll consider you to have failed.”  They’ve done research on airplane pilots. Pilots aren’t motivated by a concept of success—that the plane landed smoothly. They are motivated by the concept of failure: Do not crash the plane.

The third lever that’s really important is visibility, or exposure. It’s great to have a business plan and it’s great to have measures and targets. Yet as humans, we pay much more attention when other people see whether we performed; whether we succeeded or failed.

Number four is a leadership issue. In low-performing environments, the CEO and managers often aren’t willing to make it uncomfortable for low performers. We accept excuses and make it “okay”: “You’re selling frozen yogurt and the weather was colder than last year, so it’d ok that you missed your targets.”   Allowing excuses decreases performance.

The final driver of a low-performance environment is that the range between high performers and low performers is too great.  Having both high and low performers on the same team is always a bad sign.  The medium performers don’t strive to perform, knowing that there is no consequence for lower performance.  The high performers get arrogant and demanding, or leave.

Makes sense, doesn’t it? For a more complete treatment of this important topic, click here.


About Smart Companies Thinking Bigger®

Kelly Scanlon is the owner and publisher of Thinking Bigger Business Media. She recently finished a term on the national board of directors of the National Association of Women Business Owners, and was the national chair from 2010-2011. An advocate for small business owners, Kelly sits on numerous boards and committees to advocate on behalf of small business owners. She has won several awards for her advocacy. Among them are the 2011 United Nations NGO Positive Peace Award on behalf of Kansas City area small business owners, the U.S. Small Business Administration's Region VII Women's Business Champion of the Year in 2009, and the Women in Business Advocate of the Year from the State of Kansas in 2006. In 2002, she won the SBA's Region VII Small Business Journalist of the Year Award (Missouri, Iowa, Nebraska, Kansas). Whatever your business stage—aspiring, startup, established, mature—Thinking Bigger Business Media has the resources you need to grow to the next level. We are a resource organization dedicated to providing the strategic, "how-to" information small business owners need to become more productive and more profitable. We also provide information that helps owners connect with resources within the business community that can help them grow. We deliver that information through a variety of media products and other channels easily accessible to business owners.
This entry was posted in Ideas & Tips and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Why Dissatisfied Employees Aren’t a Bad Thing

  1. Will Palmer says:

    Kelly, this caught my eye as well after your post was published. So much so, that I printed it off and shared it with my entire team at ADP TotalSource. This will allow us to leverage different discussions around the drivers of employee productivity (something we look to impact positively for our clients). Thanks for sharing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s